Administrative

Paula Matthews

Secretary/VP/Human Resources
pamatthews@peoplesfirstinsurance.com
803-817-5930

Johanna Sipe

Automation Manager
josipe@peoplesfirstinsurance.com
803-817-5916

Lois Blumenschine

Accounting Representative
lblumenschine@peoplesfirstinsurance.com
803-817-5904

Lou Sitton

Receptionist
lsitton@peoplesfirstinsurance.com
803-817-5949

Claim Center
Carrier Links
Staff Directory

Company	Reporting Number
Accident Fund	866-206-5851
AIG	877-399-6442
Chartis Private Client Group	888-760-9195
Allied Insurance	800-282-1446
Amerisure Insurance	800-532-6230
Berkley	800-283-1153
Builders Mutual	800-809-4862
Cincinnati	Glass Claims: 877-588-4527 Workers' Comp: 877-242-2544
Eastern Alliance	800-336-3658
Encompass	800-588-7400
FCCI	800-805-3737
General Casualty	888-737-8256
GuideOne	888-748-4326
Harleysville	800-892-8877
Hartford	800-327-3636
Chubb	800-444-0604
Foremost	800-527-3907
Montgomery/Safeco	800-334-0078
National Grange	877-425-2467
Ohio Casualty	800-366-6446
Penn National	800-766-2245
Selective Insurance	866-455-9969
State Auto	800-766-1853
Travelers	800-238-6225
Zurich	800-987-3373

* Selected company will open site in a new window

Testimonials

Personal Insurance Client’s Testimonial 2

“I cannot think of a better person [than Milton Beaty] to trust such an important part of our lives with. We feel comfortable knowing that Milton is always looking out for us and we are not just another sale…It is comforting to have an agent like Milton that you can trust in tough times.”

Personal Insurance client

Personal Insurance Client’s Testimonial 1

“Milton Beaty’s access to numerous markets paired with his knowledge of the industry and superior personal service makes him an excellent choice. I highly recommend Milton and encourage you to give him a call today.”

Personal Insurance client

Web Management Client’s Testimonial

“Peoples First Insurance has been a great partner for our small business. Through all the growth and changes they have been right there with answers and direction in these times. Their solutions were right on target.”

Web Management client

Manufacturing Client’s Testimonial

“Whether it is personal, automobile, business, or workers compensation, insurance is a difficult topic no one wants to discuss. Peoples First Insurance makes that discussion easier. The agents genuinely care about their clients and don’t hesitate to ‘go that extra mile’ to be sure you understand what you are purchasing and why. They have provided
[ …more ]

Manufacturing Client

Stay Educated

Peoples First Insurance
466 Hood Center Drive • PO Box 66 • Rock Hill, SC 29730 • 803-324-5262 (Phone) • 803-329-5301 (Fax)
Business Hours: Monday - Friday: 8:15 am - 5:00 pm

Employee email | Admin